What began as a routine segment on Fox News’ Gutfeld! took a shocking turn this week when co-host Kat Timpf and veteran contributor Johnny Joey Jones shared a controversial joke about severed body parts.

The moment erupted when Jones, a retired Marine and double amputee, made a tongue-in-cheek comment about his own experience with limb loss. Kat Timpf, known for her sharp and often unfiltered humor, joined in on the joke, laughing and riffing along.

At one point, Jones quipped:

“As a fellow double amputee, I can’t tell you how hard this made me laugh.”

While some in the studio audience chuckled, the moment left many viewers at home stunned — and social media quickly caught fire.

Critics Call It “Heartless”

Outraged viewers flooded Twitter and Instagram, accusing the pair of being “insensitive” and “cruel.” Many argued that joking about such serious injuries — even when self-directed — crosses a line, especially on live television.

One angry commenter wrote:

“Millions of veterans and trauma survivors are watching. This isn’t edgy or funny. It’s just cruel.”

Others called for apologies, suggesting that Fox News should reprimand or even suspend the hosts.

Fans Defend It as “Brutal Honesty”

Despite the backlash, a large group of fans rushed to defend Timpf and Jones, praising their willingness to confront painful realities with humor. Supporters argued that dark humor can be a powerful coping mechanism, especially for those who have lived through trauma themselves.

A fellow veteran posted:

“You don’t get it unless you’ve been there. Laughter is sometimes the only thing that keeps us going.”

Many praised Jones for reclaiming his experience and turning it into something that could help others feel less alone.

The Internet Remains Divided

The incident has sparked a wider conversation about comedy, trauma, and where to draw the line. While some believe there should be strict boundaries when discussing sensitive topics, others argue that individuals who have experienced trauma should have the freedom to speak — and joke — about it on their own terms.

As the debate rages on, clips of the segment continue to circulate online, racking up millions of views and thousands of heated comments.

No Apologies (Yet)

So far, neither Timpf nor Jones has issued a formal apology. In fact, both have hinted on social media that they stand by their comments. Jones tweeted:

“If you think we’re heartless for laughing at our own scars, maybe you’ve never truly healed from yours.”

Kat Timpf echoed the sentiment, writing:

“Comedy isn’t always comfortable. That’s kind of the point.”