It’s been over a week since American Idol 2025 concluded and crowned its newest champion, Jamal Roberts. From the start, Jamal stood out as a remarkable talent, and fans are thrilled to see him take home the trophy. This season also featured a notable change on the judging panel.

Carrie Underwood joined longtime judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie this season. Bryan and Richie have been staples on the show since its 2018 revival on ABC. They previously sat alongside Katy Perry, who stepped down last season, paving the way for Underwood—a former American Idol winner herself—to take her place.

With the season wrapped up and American Idol already renewed for another year, many are wondering if Carrie Underwood will return as a judge. When asked about her plans, Underwood gave a cautious, non-committal response, saying, “I don’t know. There’s lots to contemplate.” Unlike her fellow judges, who expressed excitement about coming back, Underwood’s answer was less definitive.

Lionel Richie enthusiastically told Entertainment Weekly, “Are you kidding me? I wouldn’t miss this for the world,” while Luke Bryan shared, “We’ll get through [the finale], and then hopefully the phone will start ringing.” Their eagerness to return contrasts with Underwood’s more reserved response, which may reflect her personal considerations.

This season might have been especially challenging for Underwood given her own journey on the show. She auditioned for American Idol in 2005 during season 4 and went on to win, launching her successful career. She has openly shared how difficult it can be to say no to contestants, which could explain her hesitation to return. Having experienced the competition from the other side, she understands the emotional weight it carries.

Despite any doubts about her future on the panel, Underwood’s first season as a judge was widely praised. Her style is naturally different from Katy Perry’s, who was known for her fun and wild personality, but both brought unique energy to the show.

As of now, the release date for American Idol 2026 has not been announced, but it’s expected to premiere around February or March, continuing its tradition. Fans will be watching closely to see if Carrie Underwood returns to the judges’ table next season.