As American Idol season 23 wraps up, excitement is already building for season 24, set to premiere in 2026. While many fans are eager to see which familiar faces will return to the judges’ panel, one name stands out above the rest: Carrie Underwood.

Carrie Underwood’s Debut as an American Idol Judge

Carrie Underwood, who skyrocketed to fame after winning season 4 of American Idol, joined the show as a first-time judge during season 23. Her return to the franchise brought a wave of nostalgia and excitement, not only because she’s an Idol alum, but because she brought a fresh energy to the judges’ panel alongside Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie.

In interviews throughout the season, viewers watched as Carrie reflected on her journey from contestant to superstar, even rewearing her iconic 20-year-old finale dress in a touching tribute to her past. Her authenticity, knowledge of the music industry, and heartfelt feedback made her a standout in the new judging lineup.

Will Carrie Underwood Return for Season 24?

The big question now is: Will Carrie Underwood return as a judge on American Idol season 24? While there has been no official confirmation, recent interviews suggest there’s reason to be hopeful.

After the season 23 finale on May 18, Carrie spoke with Entertainment Tonight about her future on the show, saying:

“I don’t know! There’s lots to contemplate.”

Though vague, her comments didn’t rule out a return—and fans are holding onto that.

What Producers Are Saying About Carrie’s Future on the Show

In a separate interview with TV Line, executive producer Megan Michaels gave further insight into Carrie’s performance as a judge:

“[Carrie] really had to carve out her own role… She brought a nostalgia factor, and I also like that she brought a little criticism and constructive feedback, which is very much needed.”

Michaels emphasized Carrie’s growth in the role, noting how she adapted quickly and offered contestants a unique perspective drawn from personal experience. Her feedback was both honest and encouraging—something the show has been praised for.

So, What’s Next?

While there’s no official word yet on Carrie’s return, the combination of fan enthusiasm, producer praise, and Carrie’s open-ended statements leave the door wide open. Whether she continues in season 24 or takes another path, Carrie Underwood has once again proven why she’s such a beloved part of the American Idol legacy.