Carrie Underwood

 

After a swirl of online speculation about her reaction during the American Idol Season 23 finale, Carrie Underwood has broken her silence — and she’s making her stance unmistakably clear.

“I’m So Proud of Jamal”: Carrie’s Public Support

In an Instagram post that quickly went viral, Underwood congratulated Jamal Roberts, the newly crowned American Idol winner, writing:

“Congratulations to the newest winner of American Idol!!! I’m so proud of Jamal Roberts and all he has accomplished this season and I can’t wait to see what mountains he climbs next! He’s going to do great things!”

Her heartfelt message directly confronts and dispels the rumors suggesting she was unhappy or uncomfortable with the final outcome.

The Rumors: What Sparked the Backlash?

In the days following the May 18 finale, several fan accounts and gossip pages shared slowed-down clips from the live broadcast, alleging that Carrie appeared less enthusiastic or delayed in applauding after Roberts’ name was announced. Some even implied she may have been disappointed that John Foster, a popular frontrunner and fan favorite, did not win.

However, as many pointed out, the intense emotion and chaos of a live finale can easily lead to misinterpretation — and Underwood’s recent statement strongly reinforces that she was nothing but proud and supportive.

A Class Act: Fans Applaud Carrie’s Response

Carrie’s post was met with overwhelming positivity, drawing thousands of likes and supportive comments within hours:

“Classy as always, Carrie! Thank you for clearing the air.”
“This is the energy we need. Jamal earned this, and you’ve shown real grace in your support.”
“People love to stir drama. So glad you’re above it.”

It’s not just about setting the record straight — Underwood’s message also signals a powerful show of unity, especially important given American Idol’s diverse and growing legacy.

Jamal’s Win Makes History

Jamal Roberts’ win marked a historic moment for the franchise — he is the first African-American male winner since Ruben Studdard in 2003. A former physical education teacher from Mississippi with gospel roots, his win resonated deeply with viewers across the country.

Underwood’s public support adds a layer of validation and encouragement that only a former Idol winner and country music icon can bring.