Carrie Underwood has shared an emotional moment with fans, reflecting on the life-changing decision that led her from a small-town student to one of the biggest stars in country music.

Carrie Underwood Cries While Recalling Her “Insane” Idol Experience

In a heartfelt new video, American Idol alum and 2025 judge Carrie Underwood broke down in tears while revisiting her early days on the hit competition show. The Grammy-winning singer, now 42, opened up about how one spontaneous decision changed the course of her entire life.

“I think about my journey on American Idol all the time,” she said, holding back tears. “It’s so grand, it’s so unbelievable… If I hadn’t made that one decision in my life, my life would be completely different.”

Carrie recalled auditioning for the show on a whim, coming from a background of attending college and trying to figure out her path. The experience, she said, was nothing short of “insane.”

A Journey of Faith, Resilience, and Success

Carrie described her post-Idol career as a “blessed journey,” filled with unexpected highs and deep gratitude. She reflected on how that one audition launched her into stardom, paving the way for a successful career in music, business, and television.

The clip, shared by the official American Idol Instagram account, quickly went viral. Fans flooded the comments with admiration:

“Couldn’t have happened to a sweeter, more gentle soul.”

“Carrie Underwood is so humble and BEAUTIFUL! A great example to all.”

“A blessed journey, but also a strong work ethic combined with talent and dedication!”

Carrie Underwood’s Role as an Idol Judge Under Scrutiny

 

 

 

 

Despite her legacy, Carrie’s recent stint as a judge on American Idol hasn’t been universally praised. While some applauded her insight and calm demeanor, others felt her judging style lacked energy. One fan wrote, “She’s better as a contestant or a visitor to the show. She was a little bit boring. Sorry, but I still love her.”

Still, industry insiders say the show’s producers deeply value her contribution. A source told The U.S. Sun, “They feel a certain protectiveness toward her… they’ve defended any setbacks and criticism she’s endured this season and would gladly have her back.”

Will Carrie Return to Idol Next Season?

As the 2025 season ends, Carrie’s return remains uncertain. Insiders say the decision is in her hands, and she’s currently undecided.

“She’s on the fence about coming back,” the source said. “There were times this season I think she would’ve absolutely said ‘no’… but as she’s found her place within the role, it’s grown on her.”

Carrie Underwood’s Family and Personal Life

Carrie’s journey isn’t just professional — it’s deeply personal too. After relationships with actor Chace Crawford and NFL star Tony Romo, she married Canadian NHL player Mike Fisher in 2010. The couple now shares two sons, Isaiah and Jacob, and reside in Tennessee.

Their love story remains one of country music’s most admired. Mike even requested a trade to the Nashville Predators to be closer to Carrie, further solidifying their strong family values.