JOHN FOSTER STOPS TIME on Disney Night with emotional MUPPETS cover—audience stunned as childhood ballad becomes a HEART-WRENCHING confession in Idol’s most unexpected performance of the season

No costumes. No confetti. Just a single spotlight and a fragile note that cracked through the noise—John Foster chose “Rainbow Connection” on Disney Night, but no one was ready for what came next. With a trembling voice and tear-filled eyes, he turned a childhood melody into something heartbreakingly intimate. What was behind that quiet pain? Why did the judges look like they’d seen a ghost? And why is the internet still reeling?

Watch the performance that left the room breathless—link in the comments now.

John Foster recently lit up the American Idol stage with his gentle and touching performance of “Rainbow Connection” from The Muppets. On Disney Night during the Top 5 of Season 23, John brought something truly magical. With a soft and emotional voice, he made everyone feel like they were right there with Kermit the Frog, dreaming big dreams and wishing on stars. The lights were calm and peaceful and John stood confidently, making the song his own.

What made the moment even more special was how he stayed true to the spirit of the song while adding his flavor. “Rainbow Connection” is all about hope and wonder and John sang it with warmth that reached the hearts of the audience and judges. The judges smiled and you could see they were touched. It felt less like a contest and more like a memory being shared. His soft tone and clear notes made the performance unforgettable.

John Foster | Rainbow Connection | Top 5 Perform | American Idol 2025

Everyone watching could see how honest he was. He didn’t use any big tricks or flashy moves, just stood under the lights and sang with feeling. Sometimes that’s enough to be special. He showed fans that music can be strong even when it’s soft and simple.

Then, moving from one heartfelt moment to another, John took on “Believe” by Brooks & Dunn in the Top 7 round. This song is all about faith, loss, and holding on to something bigger than yourself and just like with “Rainbow Connection,” John brought deep emotion to this performance. His voice cracked with feeling in just the right places and the way he told the story through the lyrics gave everyone goosebumps.

John Foster | Believe | Top 7 Perform | American Idol 2025

With both performances, John Foster showed that he isn’t just a singer; he’s a storyteller. He picks songs that mean something and shares them in a way that feels honest and real. Whether he’s singing about rainbows or belief he makes you stop and listen. That’s what makes him stand out in a sea of talent.

John is clearly someone to watch, not just on American Idol but beyond. He brings kindness, passion and a unique voice to every song he sings. If you want to hear more from him and follow his journey, be sure to check out his social media pages and stay updated on what’s next for this rising star.

American Idol 2025: Audition Week 4