Carrie Underwood Caught Off-Guard by John Foster’s Finale Song—What She Said on Live TV Has Fans Questioning Everything

When John Foster stepped on stage for his finale performance, no one expected what would happen next—not even Carrie Underwood. His soul-stirring vocals struck a deep emotional chord with viewers across the country, but it was what Carrie said afterward that sparked a frenzy. Her off-script comment, delivered in a moment of awe, may have crossed a line no judge is supposed to cross. Was it pure admiration… or something more? And how did it influence the outcome of the show?

Watch the full performance that’s got everyone talking—link to the unforgettable moment below.

At just 18 years old, American Idol contestant John Foster has become one of the most talked-about performers of Season 23. With his refreshing take on timeless classics and an unmistakable vocal style, Foster has consistently captivated judges and fans alike — earning praise that suggests he may be headed all the way to the winner’s circle.

 “Rainbow Connection” – A Dream Reimagined

For his first performance on the second Disney Night episode, Foster selected “Rainbow Connection” from The Muppet Movie. At first, guest mentor Miranda Lambert encouraged him to dig deeper into the meaning of the song and form a more personal connection.

And he delivered.

Seated center stage with his acoustic guitar, Foster gave a stripped-down, heartfelt version that felt less like a performance and more like a conversation. Through every note, he told a story of hope, dreams, and perseverance — all wrapped in soft, sincere vocals.

Luke Bryan acknowledged the competitive heat of the night, saying, “Everybody’s gunning for each other and doing great, but you stayed true to yourself — and it worked.”

Lionel Richie called Foster “a true stylist” with a voice that’s “recognizable and unique.”

Carrie Underwood, beaming with pride, said: “If you’re not careful, you could win this whole thing.”

 “The Bear Necessities” – A Playful Power Move

Foster’s second performance showed off a different side — fun, energetic, and crowd-pleasing. His rendition of “The Bear Necessities” from The Jungle Book started with a soft groove before kicking into a lively swing that had the audience clapping along.

Carrie Underwood smiled, calling it a “fun throwback to childhood.”

Richie praised Foster’s “off-the-charts likability.”

Bryan said the young singer had “found a look and sound that people are clearly connecting with.”

With charm, presence, and smart song choices, Foster proved he’s not just versatile — he’s strategic.

 Top 3 Announcement: Foster Heads to the Finale

After a night of back-to-back standout performances, host Ryan Seacrest took the stage to reveal the results of over 19 million votes cast by viewers across the country.

The Top 3 finalists for American Idol Season 23 are:

John Foster

Jamal Roberts

Breanna Nix

Sadly, Thunderstorm Artis and Slater Nalley were eliminated — but their journeys left a lasting impact on the season.

 The Road to Victory: Next Stop, the Finale

With the American Idol Season 23 finale set to air on May 19, 2025, John Foster is now just one performance away from potentially claiming the title. He’ll return to his hometown for a hero’s celebration and prepare for one last chance to win America’s vote.

From heartfelt ballads to joyful Disney classics, Foster has shown range, emotion, and authenticity — and with millions now watching closely, the question remains:

Could John Foster be America’s next Idol?

🎥 Watch both of John Foster’s performances below and see why everyone is talking about this rising star.