Sometimes a song doesn’t just touch you, it wrecks you in the most beautiful way. That’s exactly what happened when John Foster stepped onto the American Idol stage and sang “Tell That Angel I Love Her.” With a shaky breath and a voice dripping with pure emotion, John didn’t just perform—he opened his heart wide and let everyone inside.

“Tell That Angel I Love Her” is a tearjerker about love, loss and longing—and John delivered every word like it was stitched into his soul. His voice, raw and trembling, made it feel like he was talking to someone he loved and lost. As he closed with the emotional line, “I love you, Maggie,” there wasn’t a dry eye left. It wasn’t just a song; it was a goodbye letter sung straight into heaven.

John Foster Sings “Tell That Angel I Love Her” | American Idol 2025

The audience couldn’t get enough. Cheers and tears filled the room and online, the floodgates opened—people calling it “the most emotional performance of the season” and “a raw, unforgettable moment.” In just a few days, John’s video racked up over 667,000 views, with fans saying they felt every single word he sang.

If John’s performance hit you right in the heart, you’ll absolutely need to hear his stunning version of “Dancing On My Own”—another powerhouse performance packed with feeling.

John Foster Full Performance | American Idol 2025 Auditions Week 4

John brings the same heart-wrenching honesty to “Dancing On My Own,” turning a pop anthem into a soulful confession. Fans online are raving that he “sings like he’s lived every word,” and it’s making even more people fall in love with his pure, real sound.

Keep up with John Foster’s journey by following his pages on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok. From heart-tugging covers to original music, he’s proving every day that real artists still exist—and they’ve got something to say.