Jessica Tarlov and the Rumors of Leaving The Five: The Truth Behind the Media Storm

In the dramatic world of Fox News, where fiery debates and opposing opinions are always in the spotlight, Jessica Tarlov has become both a beacon and, at times, the center of controversy. As one of the rare liberal political commentators on The Five, Tarlov not only brings a unique perspective but also creates memorable moments during the show’s heated discussions. However, a recent post on X has sparked a wave of controversy, claiming that Tarlov left the show in tears after a tense confrontation with her colleague, Greg Gutfeld. Is this the end of Tarlov’s journey on The Five, or just a fleeting media storm?

The Story Explodes on Social Media

On April 17, 2025, X account @LI_Islander posted a shocking message, accompanied by an image of Tarlov looking serious and emotional. The post claimed that Tarlov had a “tearful departure” from The Five, insinuating that Fox News had tried to “muzzle” Greg Gutfeld following a heated argument. The post quickly gathered numerous comments, from those criticizing Tarlov’s debate style to those vocally supporting Gutfeld as an indispensable “star” of the show. Some viewers even suggested that this could be an opportunity for The Five to “refresh” its lineup, while others expressed regret if Tarlov were to leave.

Yet, amid the frenzy of comments and speculation, one big question remains: Does what was shared on X reflect the truth?

The Truth Behind the Rumor

So far, neither Jessica Tarlov nor Fox News has made any official statements confirming her departure from The Five. In fact, reliable sources such as live.aacr.org confirmed in March 2025 that Tarlov remains a key figure on the show, despite similar rumors circulating previously. In a recent interview, Tarlov even emphasized her commitment to The Five while hinting at new projects she is pursuing. This suggests that the story of a “tearful exit” may just be an exaggeration fueled by social media.

As for Greg Gutfeld, rumors that he had been “muzzled” also seem unfounded. As one of Fox News’ key figures with his sharp humor, Gutfeld is no stranger to sparking fiery debates. Some sources, like an article from dailynewsp.com in March 2025, referenced tension between Gutfeld and Tarlov, but there is no concrete evidence that the confrontation was serious enough to drive Tarlov from the show.

Jessica Tarlov: An Irreplaceable Perspective

What makes Jessica Tarlov the focal point of these controversies? As a political strategist with an impressive academic background, Tarlov brings a rare liberal viewpoint to The Five, a show otherwise dominated by conservative perspectives. Her sharp debating skills, combined with her calm demeanor in the face of opposing opinions, have earned her a loyal following. However, these differences also make Tarlov a target for criticism, especially from those who disagree with her stance.

Whether loved or hated, there’s no denying that Tarlov has left her mark. Her exchanges with colleagues like Jesse Watters and Dana Perino are not just entertaining but also highlight the value of diverse viewpoints in a program like The Five. If Tarlov does indeed leave, it would be a major loss—not only for the show but for viewers who appreciate the balance she brings.

Conclusion: Will the Storm Pass?

In the era of social media, where a single post can spark endless speculation, the story of Jessica Tarlov and The Five serves as a reminder of the importance of fact-checking. As of now, all signs indicate that Tarlov continues her journey at Fox News, and the rumors of her departure might just be a “storm in a teacup.” However, in the unpredictable world of television, nothing is certain.

Will Jessica Tarlov continue to be the voice of freedom on The Five, or will she one day choose a new path? Only time will tell. For now, keep watching—because with Tarlov, everything is always worth waiting for.