Things got fiery on Fox News’ The Five when a discussion on immigration took a surprising turn, resulting in a heated exchange between co-hosts Jessica Tarlov and Jeanine Pirro. The clash unfolded live, leaving viewers stunned as Tarlov directly challenged Pirro’s stance, demanding transparency with the memorable line, “Be honest about it!”

The dramatic moment was sparked by the Trump administration’s controversial deportation of hundreds of immigrants to El Salvador, despite a court order calling for an immediate halt to the flights. Tarlov strongly criticized the administration’s actions, suggesting they signaled the collapse of America’s asylum system.

“I’m just saying if you don’t believe in due process anymore then be honest about it, because that’s what’s going on here,” Tarlov asserted passionately.

Pirro, a former judge and prosecutor known for her tough stances, fired back sharply. “The only due process I believe in is the legal way to enter this country,” Pirro responded.

“But claiming asylum is legal,” Tarlov quickly countered, emphasizing the legitimacy of the immigrants’ rights under U.S. law.

The tension escalated further when Pirro sarcastically dismissed Tarlov’s concern that immigrants were being “disappeared” from scheduled court appearances, quipping mockingly, “Being disappeared—Americans are being disappeared.”

The explosive debate highlighted stark differences in perspectives on immigration policy, specifically around the Trump administration’s use of a rarely invoked 18th-century wartime law to deport individuals allegedly affiliated with Venezuelan gangs without full judicial review.

Tarlov pointed to credible claims from immigration attorneys about clients scheduled for hearings suddenly vanishing, questioning the legality and transparency of the administration’s methods. Pirro, meanwhile, firmly reiterated that asylum claims must follow the proper legal channels, dismissing concerns about due-process violations.

The heated exchange was part of a broader controversy, as U.S. District Judge James E. Boasberg had previously ordered a halt to these deportation flights—an order issued while flights were already midair. The Trump administration, via White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt, argued there was “no lawful basis” to comply, asserting the flights were outside U.S. jurisdiction. Judge Boasberg responded with skepticism, demanding further explanation from Justice Department attorneys.

This on-air conflict between Tarlov and Pirro not only captivated viewers but has intensified discussions surrounding immigration policy and due process rights. Social media exploded with reactions, some praising Tarlov’s bold stance and others supporting Pirro’s firm response.

As debates continue to heat up, audiences are left wondering whether this dramatic on-air dispute was just another spirited debate—or a sign of deeper tensions brewing behind the scenes at Fox News.

Stay tuned for further updates—because with passionate personalities like Tarlov and Pirro at the helm, there’s sure to be more dramatic exchanges ahead!