Jessica Tarlov and Elon Musk Clash in Heated Debate on The Five

Jessica Tarlov, the liberal political commentator on The Five at Fox News, and Elon Musk, the billionaire head of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), had a notable clash on April 1, 2025, when Musk appeared as a guest on the show. The confrontation not only heated up the studio but also caused a social media storm with mixed reactions.

On Fox News' "The Five," Jessica Tarlov is redefining the image of the  sacrificial liberal | Salon.com

The Cause of the Debate

The discussion centered around Musk’s role in DOGE and accusations of conflicts of interest. Jessica directly questioned Musk about DOGE’s budget cuts to various government agencies—such as the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)—which have either investigated or are currently investigating Musk’s companies, Tesla and SpaceX. She asked: “You’re cutting agencies that oversee your businesses, while Tesla and SpaceX receive billions in government contracts. How do you explain this to the American people?”

Musk responded by emphasizing DOGE’s “complete transparency,” asserting that all decisions are made public and that “if anyone has questions, they can raise them.” However, Jessica was unsatisfied with this answer, calling it an attempt to dodge the issue. She continued: “Transparency is good, but when you’re both the player and the referee, how can people trust that?”

Elon Musk's grip on Tesla loosens

The Exchange and Reactions

The exchange became tense when Musk shifted the focus, stating that DOGE is focused on eliminating waste, not protecting his personal interests. He jokingly added, “If I wanted to make money, I wouldn’t be doing this—I lose hours of sleep over it!” Jessica fired back: “The public doesn’t care how much sleep you lose, they want to know their tax dollars aren’t lining your pockets.”

Viewers on X split into two camps. Some praised Jessica for taking on Musk, with one user writing: “Tarlov asked the question everyone’s thinking!” On the other hand, Musk’s fans argued that she was merely trying to “trap” him without offering any alternative solutions. The video of the heated exchange quickly went viral, amassing millions of views in just a few days.

Fox's Jessica Tarlov Confronts Musk Over DOGE Conflicts

Context and Significance

This wasn’t the first time Jessica Tarlov challenged Musk. In February 2025, she criticized him on air for DOGE’s budget cuts to USAID, calling it “an irresponsible move.” For Musk, this appearance was an opportunity to defend DOGE, but he was pushed into a tough position when facing Jessica’s sharp questioning. The debate highlighted the ideological divide: Jessica represented the skeptical voice against unchecked power, while Musk defended his vision of “efficiency.”

Although there’s no direct evidence showing that Musk personally benefits from DOGE, Jessica’s question touched on a sensitive issue: how can a billionaire with a vast business empire be impartial when influencing government policy? This drama wasn’t just a personal verbal sparring match, but also reflected larger tensions in today’s U.S. politics.