Thousands Petition to Replace Jessica Tarlov on The Five, and FOX News’ Official Announcement Last Night Left Everyone in Shock

On the evening of April 15, 2025, FOX News made a bombshell announcement that left viewers reeling: political commentator Jessica Tarlov, a long-time co-host of The Five, has officially departed the network. The announcement followed a wave of petitions from thousands of viewers calling for her replacement, citing concerns over her liberal viewpoints and clashes with her co-hosts. The statement from FOX News was nothing short of astonishing, revealing an unexpected turn of events that has sparked widespread speculation and left many in disbelief.

 

Navigating Pregnancy and New Motherhood in the Spotlight With Jessica Tarlov  – Podcast Ep 151

 

The Backlash: Why Viewers Wanted Tarlov Gone

Over the past several months, Jessica Tarlov’s tenure on The Five had been a lightning rod for controversy. Known for her strong liberal views, Tarlov had become a polarizing figure on the show, frequently engaging in heated debates with her conservative counterparts, most notably Greg Gutfeld. While some viewers admired her courage in challenging the network’s conservative bias, others expressed frustration over her perceived alignment with liberal ideologies that clashed with the core audience of The Five.

The backlash against Tarlov reached a fever pitch in the months leading up to her departure. Thousands of viewers, many conservative, voiced their concerns over her presence on the show, signing petitions and flooding social media with demands for her replacement. The tension between Tarlov’s political views and the conservative nature of the show created a significant divide among viewers, with some calling for her removal to preserve the integrity of The Five’s dynamic.

The petitions garnered widespread attention, especially after a particularly tense exchange between Tarlov and Gutfeld during a segment in which she voiced her criticism of the Trump administration’s economic policies. This moment, which some viewers described as a “breaking point,” pushed the conversation into the national spotlight. The outcry from fans who felt that Tarlov was no longer a good fit for The Five reached its peak as her resignation became imminent.

 

Fox News' Jessica Tarlov Slams Claims About California Fires - Parade

 

The Official Announcement: A Shocking Turn of Events

In a statement released by FOX News last night, the network confirmed that Tarlov would be stepping away from her role on The Five. The announcement, however, raised more questions than answers. While the network attributed her departure to “personal reasons” and “new opportunities,” rumors quickly surfaced that the decision was the result of mounting pressure from viewers and executives alike.

The shockwaves from the announcement rippled through the media world, with many questioning whether the pressure from petitions and public outcry had influenced the decision. While Tarlov had previously expressed her desire to explore new career opportunities, including running for political office, the timing of her departure—coming after months of intense scrutiny—seemed too coincidental for many to dismiss.

FOX News’ announcement did little to clarify whether Tarlov had voluntarily left or was asked to step down due to mounting tensions within the network. What was clear, however, was that her exit had been brewing for some time, and the official confirmation of her departure was the culmination of a prolonged and highly publicized dispute.

Tarlov’s Departure: A Complex Situation

Tarlov’s departure from The Five is not as simple as a resignation or a firing. The decision involved a complex mix of factors, including internal pressures within FOX News, the shifting landscape of public opinion, and Tarlov’s own career ambitions. Sources within the network suggested that Tarlov’s increasingly vocal liberal viewpoints were becoming a liability, particularly in the wake of former President Trump’s ongoing attacks on the network’s credibility. As the political climate grew more polarized, Tarlov’s clashes with her more conservative co-hosts were seen by some as a distraction that detracted from the show’s intended tone.

Tarlov had always expressed a desire to expand her professional horizons, and her decision to leave may have been influenced by a combination of personal aspirations and the demands of her role at FOX News. However, the widespread calls for her replacement, particularly after the eruption of tension on the show, cannot be overlooked as a significant factor in her exit. The shifting dynamics of The Five, where political disagreements often escalate into public confrontations, may have contributed to her decision to seek a new path outside of the network.

 

How Jessica Tarlov of 'The Five' became a liberal star on Fox News - Los  Angeles Times

 

The Future of The Five and FOX News

With Tarlov’s departure, the future of The Five remains uncertain. The show, which has long been a staple of FOX News’ evening programming, is known for its dynamic and often heated discussions between conservative and liberal voices. Tarlov’s exit leaves a gap that will likely be filled by a new co-host, but the question remains whether the show will maintain its bipartisan balance or if the tone will shift further toward one side of the political spectrum.

For FOX News, the departure of a prominent figure like Tarlov raises questions about the network’s future direction. Will it continue to embrace a broad range of political perspectives, or will it lean even more heavily into conservative viewpoints to cater to its base? Tarlov’s exit could signal a shift in the network’s approach to political commentary, especially as viewers demand more alignment with their ideological preferences.

As Tarlov moves on to explore new opportunities—rumored to include political aspirations—her departure marks the end of an era for The Five. The show’s format, which has always balanced different political viewpoints, may now see changes in how those views are represented. Tarlov’s exit also signals a broader trend within the media world, where political polarization is increasingly influencing network programming decisions.

The Impact on Tarlov’s Career

While her departure from The Five might seem like the end of an era for Tarlov’s career at FOX News, it could very well be the beginning of a new chapter. Tarlov has expressed an interest in running for political office, and her experience on The Five has given her a significant platform to launch such a campaign. As a well-known figure in the political commentary world, Tarlov has the potential to leverage her public profile to gain support for future endeavors, whether in politics or other forms of media.

Tarlov’s departure has also sparked discussions about the role of women in political commentary, particularly in a male-dominated field. While she faced criticism for her liberal views, Tarlov’s ability to hold her own in debates with more conservative personalities demonstrated her resilience and expertise. Whether she chooses to stay in the media or pivot to a political career, Tarlov’s influence and voice will likely continue to resonate in the public sphere.

 

How Jessica Tarlov of 'The Five' Became a Liberal Star on Fox News - The  New York Times

 

Conclusion: What’s Next for Jessica Tarlov and FOX News?

Jessica Tarlov’s departure from The Five has shocked the media world, leaving fans and critics alike wondering what motivated her exit. The mounting pressure from viewers and colleagues, combined with her own career aspirations, led to a decision that will have lasting implications for both Tarlov and the network. As FOX News moves forward without her, it will be interesting to see how the show evolves and whether it will remain committed to offering diverse political perspectives or whether it will lean further into its conservative base.

Tarlov’s exit also raises questions about the intersection of media, politics, and public opinion. As networks face increasing pressure to align with their audiences’ political views, the media landscape is being reshaped by these demands. The next phase of Tarlov’s career, whether in politics or media, will undoubtedly attract attention, and her departure from The Five marks a significant turning point in her journey.

Fans and critics alike will be watching closely as Tarlov embarks on her next venture, and FOX News will have to navigate the challenges of maintaining its audience while dealing with the shifting tides of political commentary.